Peanut Butter


Have a craving for peanut butter? Really who doesn’t? This cookie is sure to scratch that itch! The Critter will satisfy the peanut butter fan and leave you wanting more. Real, rich and creamy peanut butter is blended with our famous cookie batter and baked to perfection to make a cookie that is unrivaled in its peanut buttery goodness.

  • 1-3 cookies: $2.00/each
  • 4-7 cookies: $1.75/each
  • 8-100 cookies: $1.50/each
  • 1 dozen: Get a free cookie
  • 2 dozen: Get 2 free cookies
  • Orders over 100: $1.00/each
Price reflected in cart.